Why Starting a New Film Cue Is Still the Hardest Part
Starting a new cue is still one of the most difficult parts of film scoring for me.
That may sound strange after years of composing and teaching film scoring.
I know the techniques. I have workflows and frameworks that help me understand a scene. I have a large orchestral template ready to go. Often, I have a temp track that gives me a good indication of what the director is responding to.
All of those things help. But none of them completely removes that uncomfortable moment when I open a new scene, place the cursor at the beginning, and have to decide what the music is actually going to be.
Experience doesn't necessarily make that moment disappear. What it gives you is more ways to find your way out of it.
The Obvious Scenes Aren't Always the Hardest
Interestingly, some of the scenes that look the most difficult aren't necessarily the hardest to start.
If I'm looking at a large action sequence, I already have important information. There is energy, movement, danger, and usually a clear dramatic direction. I can begin thinking about pulse, orchestration, rhythmic density, tempo, and how the music will follow or counter the action.
The same can happen with comedy, suspense, or a deeply emotional scene. I'm not saying those scenes are easy to score—they can be extremely difficult to get right—but at least they give you a relatively clear musical problem to solve.
I often find the hardest scenes are the ones that aren't obviously anything.
It's a conversation, but it isn't particularly sad or funny. Something important may be happening, but the scene isn't asking for a strong emotional statement. Perhaps there are subtle changes in the characters' relationships, a little uncertainty, some warmth, and then a hint that something else is coming.
The director wants music underneath it.
Now what?
This is where film scoring becomes particularly interesting. The music needs to do something without appearing to do too much. It needs to give the scene a point of view, support its pacing, and sometimes connect several subtle emotional changes without suddenly announcing to the audience, "This is the emotion you should be feeling."
Finding the musical identity of that kind of scene can take me much longer than finding an idea for an action sequence.
The Temp Track Helps—But It Doesn't Write the Cue
A temp track can be incredibly useful in these situations. It can tell you something about pacing, density, instrumentation, or simply what the filmmakers have become accustomed to hearing against the scene.
I don't see temp music as something that necessarily limits creativity. Used properly, it can provide valuable information.
But understanding why the temp works is different from knowing what your own cue should be.
Maybe the director likes the sense of movement in the temp, but not its harmony. Maybe it's the instrumentation that makes the scene work. Maybe it's simply the fact that the music remains restrained for two minutes and then grows at exactly the right moment.
The challenge is identifying the function behind the temp rather than simply reproducing its surface.
And even after you've figured that out, you still have to find your first idea.
Sometimes a Piano Sketch Is the Wrong Answer
One of my favorite ways to get away from that pressure is to leave the DAW and go to the piano.
Removing all the technology can be incredibly helpful. Instead of thinking about libraries, articulations, MIDI programming, routing, and mixing, I can think about the scene by itself. What should this moment feel like? What should change emotionally between the beginning and the end?
Very often, a simple piano sketch gives me the answer. I find a harmonic idea, a melody, or even just two chords that establish the right emotional direction. Once that exists, I can return to the DAW and begin building the cue around it.
But sometimes a piano sketch is the wrong answer.
Not every cue needs a chord progression. Not every scene needs a melody. In fact, trying to find an interesting harmonic progression can sometimes send me in exactly the wrong direction.
Some scenes need to live primarily in texture, color, rhythm, or movement. The emotional idea may be contained in the sound itself rather than in something that can be meaningfully reduced to piano.
In those situations, a particular timbre can provide more inspiration than twenty minutes of searching for chords. It might be the attack of a trumpet, an unusual horn texture, a low string pattern, a percussion sound, a synth, or some instrument I haven't used in months. I hear it against the picture and suddenly understand what kind of musical world the scene belongs in.
The sound becomes the first idea.
From there, the composition begins to reveal itself.
Your Template Can Be a Creative Tool
This is one of the reasons I find a good template so valuable. Of course, there are practical benefits. Having instruments loaded, routed, balanced, and ready to record saves time. When deadlines are tight, that matters enormously.
But I think there's another benefit that gets discussed less often: a template reminds you of the sounds you have forgotten you own.
Most composers eventually accumulate an absurd number of sounds. We buy a library because it inspires us, use it on a project, and six months later we barely remember it's installed.
Without a template, it's very easy to keep reaching for the same instruments simply because they're the ones we remember.
When I'm searching through my template, I'll occasionally see an instrument and think, "I completely forgot about this." I'll play it against the scene, and sometimes that unexpected color is exactly what I was missing.
In that sense, a template isn't only about efficiency. It can become a map of your available colors.
The important thing is not to let the template dictate the orchestration. Having 150 tracks available doesn't mean the cue needs 150 tracks. Sometimes the discovery of one unusual sound allows you to delete ten other ideas.
Transitions Are Crucial
For me, transitions are one of the places where the real craft of film scoring becomes apparent.
Writing 20 seconds that sound mysterious may not be particularly difficult. Writing another 20 seconds that feel warm may not be difficult either. Making the audience accept that the first idea naturally transformed into the second is a completely different problem.
A transition doesn't always need a new chord progression. It might happen because one instrument remains while everything else changes around it. A rhythmic figure might gradually transform. A sustained note might acquire a different harmonic meaning. A texture might slowly become pitched material. Sometimes the orchestration changes before the harmony does, preparing the audience for the next emotional state.
And sometimes the best transition is simply knowing when to stop.
I can spend a surprising amount of time working on a few seconds between two sections of a cue. But those few seconds can determine whether the finished piece feels like a collection of musical ideas placed against a picture or a single thought evolving with the scene.
Experience Gives You More Places to Look
I don't think the goal is to reach a point where starting a cue becomes effortless. At least, that hasn't happened for me.
What has changed is that I have more places to look when the first idea isn't coming.
I can study the temp more carefully and ask what it's actually doing for the scene. I can step away from the DAW and try the piano. I can decide that the piano is exactly the wrong tool and search for a texture instead. I can explore the sounds sitting in my template. I can divide a complicated scene into smaller emotional sections. Sometimes I'll even work on a later moment first and discover that it tells me what the beginning needs to be.
Techniques, frameworks, templates, and experience all make this process easier to navigate. But there's still a moment when I have to find something that connects emotionally with the picture.
And when I finally find it—even if it's only a tiny rhythmic gesture, an unusual texture, or one interesting sound—the entire process changes.
I'm no longer trying to figure out how to start.
I'm composing.
If starting a new cue still feels difficult sometimes, even after years of composing, I'd love to know I'm not the only one.
Does the beginning feel like the hardest part for you too? What helps you find that first idea?
Leave a comment below and share your process. I'd genuinely love to hear how other composers approach that blank timeline.
Sometimes, the right sound is the starting point.
Explore instruments I've created to help composers find ideas and keep the creative process moving.
Comments